Sunday, September 10, 2006

Live blogging of New Zealand screening of The Path to 9/11

Well, the TV One screening of Path to 9/11 has screened, and I've attempted to do a live blog - particularly so that those of you in the US can get a handle on what you (may or may not) see tomorrow; so you have time to figure out the details of what's correct and what's been falsified or made up; and so that we can compare the NZ version with the US version, to see if anything's been changed by ABC/Disney by the time you guys get to see it.

Apologies in advance for any typos (and appalling mis-spellings of names of famous Americans!) - I've now tidied it all up so it makes more sense.

Screening on TV One begins with a BIG disclaimer:

Due to subject matter, viewer discretion is advised.

The following movie is a dramatization that is drawn from a variety of sources including the 9/11 Commission Report and other published materials, and from personal interviews. The movie is not a documentary.

For dramatic and narrative purposes, the movie contains fictionalized scenes, composite and representative characters and dialogue, as well as time compression.

Credits. Scenes of NY streets. Classical music.

On-screen text:
Based in part on the book “The Cell” by John Miller and Michael Stone
On-screen text:
The 9/11 Commission is an independent, bipartisan commission created by congress in late 2002.

"Our aim has not been to assign individual blame. Our aim has been to provide the fullest possible account of the events surrounding 9/11 and to identify lessons learned"

"In an event of this scale, touching so many issues and organizations, we are conscious of our limits"
- 9/11 Commission

Busy airport - Logan International, Boston. 7.13am, September 11, 2001. Passengers checking in to United flight. Muhammad Atta checking in. Warning on screen about him. Allowed through. Employee asks should he be searched? No, just hold their bags until they board. Checking bags packed by other terrorists. They go through OK.

John O'Neill, Director of Security, WTC (retired FBI agent), arrives for work and reminds security to check his sticker, "...even if he knows me. No-one gets in the building without a sticker!"

Dulles Airport Washington DC 7.15am. Salem al-Hazmi checks in. No photo id. Employee instructs baggage handler to “hold these bags off the plane until they have boarded”

Terrorists boarding aircraft, hand luggage being x-rayed and allowed through.

John O’Neill arrives at office.

Planes takes off, terrorists on different planes call each other on cellphones “we are about to take off - all is good" "it’s good here too" "God is great” terrorists look nervous. Told to turn off their cellphones by stewardess.

Flying view over water towards Manhattan and WTC...

8.5 yrs earlier - February 26, 1993.

NY city streets, WTC aerial view, yellow truck pulls into car park under WTC.

Ramzi Yousef (Palestinian engineer) is one of the people in the truck.

Parks in reserved spot, leaves keys in vehicle, one guys gets out and gets into another car and drives off. Security guards not paying attention.

Others prepare the bomb. Mahmoud "The Red" Abouhalima (Egyptian cab driver), Mohammad A. Salameh (Jordanian).

Bombs set in truck. Speaking Arabic (praying). Light fuses, get into other vehicles and leave fast.

Still security not paying attention. Bombers are trying to get out of car park – honking with impatience. Bomb’s about to blow - stuck in queue to get out. Finally get out, drive like mad, woman in office notices. Vehicles hurtle out of car park and onto busy NY street.

Fire starts in van, fills up with smoke and blows up huge explosions everywhere, people getting hurt, fireball.

News report.

Emad Salem (immigrant from Egypt, ex-colonel, Egyptian army) watches news report at home.

Nancy Floyd (FBI special agent, NY office) watches on her TV while packing.

Bombers arrive on the shoreline to the S of Manhatten to watch the WTC destruction from a distance.

NY Fire House 10 first on scene.

Breathing equipment, fire, smoke, water, darkness, torchlight.

Emad calls Nancy and tells her he told her it would happen. "You know who this is, don't you Nancy? I don't understand your FBI! These people - they don't listen!" She says: “They don’t believe people are smart enough to pull this off. You did the best you could. We both did the best we could!” He says “I’m afraid they will come and get me!”

Terrorists watch WTC from across water to S, not happy, buildings were supposed to fall into each other. Have to go! Now!

Fire team break through into car park.

Nancy to Emad: "Let’s see what happens and if anyone contacts you, page me."

News report: Suspected to have been a truck bomb, no idea of perpetrators, number of organisations claiming responsibility.

Ramzi Yousef sees report on news while at airport waiting to leave country. Calls crime hotline and claims responsibility on behalf of the 5th Batallion of the Liberation Army. Action was against Americans for govt’s politic, economic and military support of Israel.

Nancy arrives at work at FBI NY office - February 27 1993.
Meets Neil Herman (FBI supervising special agent) and Lou Napoli (NYPD detective - joint terrorism task force). Lou: "this isn't our guys is it? The guys your informant turned us on to? We were tailing them, remember?" "Will he come in?"

Nancy remembers only too well - "he was the best mole we ever had and he came to them - and they shut him down because he wanted $500/week" Napoli says it was an upstairs decision and that he didn't want to lose him either.

"You guys were wrong why won’t you admit it?" "Call him and see if he'll talk to us."

Bomb squad detective in cleanup of WTC finds part from bomb truck. Worried about avalanche caused by vibrations from subway train - can't move evidence, but the piece has an ID number which could allow them to identify it, trains being tested nearby which could destroy the evidence. Not allowed, but they remove it anyway.

Asked by boss if they removed evidence. Yes. Boss: "Nothing was to be removed! Could blow whole case." Crime wagon took it to the lab. Boss: "FBI case - not NYPD or Port Authority. Don’t think – just follow orders!"

VIN number belongs to Salameh's truck – he wants deposit back - reported stolen. FBI Neil Herman v excited. Lou: "So it was those guys?" "Yeah."

Salameh was friend of guy who shot Jewish defence league rabbi in attempted assasination 3 years ago. These guys were questioned but never charged.

FBI watching rental company surveillance. Salameh comes in about stolen van. Fill out form. Has no keys (left in van) $200 settlement. Wants $400. FBI getting nervous. Signs form. Cash handed over. Initiate the takedown. FBI moves in. Salameh arrested.

Under WTC – cleanup. On news: "Joint Terrorism Task force arrested Mohamad Salameh". Cleanuppers cheer.

John Miller (news correspondent) meets Neil Herman in a bar.

Neil: "John it’s BS - we were tailing those guys since the rabbi shooting we knew they were up to no good but we couldn't convince guys upstairs. Caught up with little guys, only luck, like Keystone Cops. Miracle that only 6 people killed. Any idea how bad it could have been? Sending John O'Neill to Washington. Chief of Counter-Terrorism. Plan to catch the big fish."

Lou Napoli and FBI team meet Emad.
Emad: "6 months ago I told you something might happen. But the FBI fired me 'cos I wanted to get paid."
FBI guy: "You wouldn't testify and investigations can't go on for ever. Individuals have the right to be protected from domestic spying."
Emad: "Don’t they have the right to be protected against terrorists? They want to bring down both buildings and kill as many people as possible! I read every day in the newspapers how the FBI are heroes, no-one knows the truth, huh?"
Nancy: "We want to reactivate you and put you back in."
Emad: "They are still out there - the members of the cell. Mosques been taken over by fundamentalists."
Nancy: "Are you willing to work with us again?
Napoli: "Got to be prepared to testify. We want the sheikh. But there's two guys we really want - the masterminds - Rashid the bomb-maker and 'The Red.'"
Emad: "Rashid - met him only once. Quiet, smart. "The Red" I know well. Not shown up for work. What will you pay?"

Napoli to Nancy in FBI office: "Clearance to restart relationship with Emad. $1.5mil. They sweated before they signed off on it."

Khalid Sheikh Muhammad (Ramzi Yousef's uncle) at club/party in Manilla, Philippines, 1993.

Talking about bomb with nephew, Ramzi Yousef (Rashid the bomb maker). "Once the American people realise that their government's policies put them in danger, they will change those policies"

Yousef tells him he is working on something incredible – bomb that can blow up a plane, cannot be detected - developed into mould like gelatine, can be placed inside anything. Detonator – casio watch.
Yousef: "A dozen planes in one day. We will kill thousands – needs money to do it properly with professionals."
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed: "There's a wealthy Saudi - we fought together against the Russians in Afghanistan"
Yousef: “I’ll knock those towers down... someday!”

Amad calls Nancy from outside mosque: "'The Red' is in Egypt – they arrested him - they haven’t told you - you must do something! He's been arrested for assassination of Egyptian president Sadat! They will torture and kill him!"

'Blind Sheikh" being hassled by media outside mosque re: connection to WTC bombing.

Helicopters with armed guards arriving in NY, handcuffed man being taken away.

Mahmoud ('The Red') being interviewed by FBI – FBI got him out of Egypt. FBI have him. He’s been tortured. Flashbacks of torture. They say they won’t hurt him. "We're not gonna torture you here. We don't do that. Did they hurt you? I hear the Egyptian Scret Police are pretty tough guys... Can you help us? Will you help us?" Trying to make connection with the Blind Sheikh who ordered murder of an associate by Red.

Want all his info about Blind Sheikh and Ramzi Yousef. He can talk to an attourney and get a better deal. They don't want him for the WTC bombing, they just want all his info.
Emad meets with FBI – he has taped conversation with Blind Sheikh where he talks about war with America. "We must kill American soldiers, attack military targets. Is it enough for an arrest?"

"We'll have to check with Janet Reno - see if she has any balls." She has to approve an arrest.

News report on Blind Sheikh’s arrest.

FBI Briefing. Herman: "Rashid the Iraqi – Ramzi Yousef pic – this is our guy, the mastermind behind the attack. Left NY for Pakistan - his home."
Frank Pellegrino: "Explanation of two agencies in Pakistan FIA (like FBI) and ISI (like CIA). They hate each other. Someone in FIA (as Pakistan is very anti-American) could have warned Yousef at the last minute. Missed arresting him by 2 hours. Committed to murder and mayhem. We must get him. Achilles heel is his brazenness. Placed bomb outside Prime Minister-to-be Benazir Butto’s home but mucked it up. Injured (damaged left eye and fingers). Prime suspect in bomb in a mosque in Iran. Why would a Muslim try to assassinate his PM or blow up mosque? Benazir Butto is a woman (first female head of state). He is a Sunni. Anti Shia (hence anti-Iranian). FBI’s most wanted man. We believe he's in the Philippines."

Bomber (Yousef) on Philippines airlines plane setting up bomb in toilets. He gets off at Narita. Passenger in his seat (where he's put the bomb) gets blown up after plane takes off again.

John O’Neill (now FBI Counterterrorism Division): “Yousef is practicing, he will learn from this and try again. I'm going to DC early - get things started.”

Yousef building bombs at home above the club in the Philippines. Accidentally starts a fire. Leaves laptop, files and address book in building, sends a mate (Murad) to get them, who gets arrested. Murad tries to run but gets caught “The two Satans must be destroyed!”

Police find laptop and open it. "Do we need a warrant" Well get one"

Richard Clarke (National Co-ordinator Counterterrorism - NCC) press conference. Afterwards meets with “Kirk” FBI field agent. Talks about finding laptop with info on "Day of Death" plot to hijack a dozen airliners in a single day. Kill 4,000 people. All US carriers - bound for LA, SF, Honolulu and NY. Also assassinate Clinton and the Pope. Small bomb with each hijkacker. Suicide mission. Man arrested in Manilla was a commercial airlines pilot. "When was this supposed to happen?" "Same day as Pope’s visit – Friday."

John O’Neill wants to meet a bunch of people. Richard Clarke from White House calls him about info on Yousef.

O'Neill meets up with Lou, Herman and others at FBI.

They discuss Ramzi Yousef – bomb factory exposed, cell broken, on way to Pakistan. "We need to pinpoint him and get him out of there fast. No lawyers getting in our way. We cover our bases."

Herman: "We could never look at that laptop if that happened here. All that evidence - inadmissable. It’s a new kind of war, and if preventions’ our duty…" O'Neill: "His rap sheet's a mile long. We won’t lose this guy."

Islamabad, Pakistan - US embassy - Feb 4, 1995.

Man approaches embassy gate to get in, but walks away when he sees security. Passes note to soldier at back gate – pic of Yousef wanted poster. Gets inside embassy. Very nervous. Wants no-one to know he’s there. Will be murdered if anyone knows him. Gives explanation of why Yousef has become a martyr. No work, people get angry. This is all they can do. Bill Miller and Scott Randall (Diplomatic Security Service) ask for verification that he knows Yousef. Informer says that Yousef lost his laptop in Manila. Has a new one now. Sometimes leaves it with this informer.

They discuss it with FBI back in US by video link. Believe the informer is for real. Has provided them with info about more attacks. He doesn't believe in killing innocents, which is why he's informing. US officials in Pakistan believe they have to move fast - before Yousef does. O’Neill says he must contact State Dept. Get permission from Butto.
US official: "That's very risky, John. Needs absolute security."
O'Neill: "She'll give it"
US official: "But he's a rock star here! He has friends high up in the government."
O'Neill: I'll take care of it. Get as many agencies as you can - whoever you can trust. Contact the embassy - tell them it's the real deal - 6 hours".

Meeting with Clarke at his home at night.
Clarke: "Tell O'Neill I'll back him all the way on this but when it comes to pulling the trigger - he needs approval. Up and down the line. He can't be a cowboy on this."

O'Neill is calling someone about the "Rendition Plan" (which will take place when they catch Yousef). "If our planes don't have clearance to land... I don't care! This top priority!"

Informer (Ishtiak) calls Miller. He has spoken to Yousef and has been invited to dinner. "What should I do?" "Have dinner with him." "I won’t know where until closer to the time." "Try to find out where he’s staying." "We won't arrest him in public - it's too dangerous. Don't worry" Informer very scared – doesn’t want to be led into a trap. Doesn’t want them to tail him.

Ishtiak arrives home to find Yousef and his uncle (Khalid Sheikh) waiting for him. They show him the bomb in a chessboard box. They are sending him on a flight this evening. Yousef will be on one too. Islamabad to Bankok to US. "You plant the bomb and leave the aircraft in Bangkok. Once over Pacific it will blow up." "But I have no passport!" "We have one for you." He’s very scared.

Ishtiak calls US officials, warning them what's going to happen.

Scott: "My wife’s on that flight!" Miller: "We can’t have Americans changing flights or they will figure it out. No-one's getting on that plane - but if we're gonna arrest them they have to think everything's normal."
Asks Pakistani Colonel how they can have let this happen.
Pakistani official: "Do you want to point fingers, make accusations or arrest this animal and protect your wife?"

Ishtiak calls again to say the plan’s changed again. "No bombs on any planes?" "Not as far as I know." "That's not not good enough!" "He will kill me and my family if he finds out!"

Miller: "What info do you have?"
Ishtiak: "He intends to leave for Peshawar tomorrow. He intends to cross to Afghanistan. He doesn't know. I'm meeting him tomorrow morning." Gives them Yousef's hotel address. Doesn't know if he's there now.
Miller: "We'll have to go back to the embassy and talk to John. Maybe we can get him tomorrow."

Talk to O'Neill by phone. Haven't confirmed Yousef is in the hotel because they don't want him tipped off. Want authorisation.
Pakistani Colonel: "Prime Minister has given me sole authority"
Miller to O'Neill: "Do we have authority?"
Herman to O'Neill: "John - we have got to get authority! We can't do this alone!"
O'Neill: "Justice, Langley and NSC will hang you up if you get this wrong."
O'Neill to Miller: "Place your men. I’ll get a decision."

Ishtiak walking through streets. DSS/Pakistani authorities in position.

Yousef: "We are going to Afghanistan to teach mujehaddin about bombing. You will meet 'The Tall One' who finances our efforts. He’s a great man. He has asked me to come and share my knowledge, we are in a new movement to change the world. Will take the 12 o’clock bus to Peshawar and then across the border, wake me up before noon."

Ishtiak goes to buy a newspaper. He gives signal to watching men. They place call to John O’Neill. "We can get him!" O'Neill puts him on hold - Director Freed is on the other line.

Freed: "I want Bill Gabin to arrest him"
O'Neill: "But he's not there!"
Freed: "He's on his way with 20 other agents and a rendition team."
O'Neill: "But he's on his way to Afghanistan! This might be our only opportunity!"
Freed: "Just keep an eye on him - he’s not going anywhere."
O'Neill: "He might if 20 FBI agents turn up at the airport!"
Freed: "This isn’t my decision. Secretary of State is coordinating with Benazir Butto. There are other agencies involved! I’ll call you back!"

They have to wait.

Back at FBI there’s a phone call - Director Freed gave go-ahead. Go! Now!

They catch Yousef asleep in bed and arrest him. Maps of NY, passports in his room. Weapons, bomb-making equipment.

Locals are not happy. Pakistani police move in to keep people calm.

Yousef’s uncle realises what has happened and slips away.

In car on way to airport Miller wants to know from Yousef who’s financing the operation. Is it Saddam? Revenge for the Gulf War? Who are you going to see in Afghanistan? Pakistani Colonel asks for 1 hour with him (to get all answers they want...). Miller refuses.

Ishtiak and family leaving in haste for US with US official. Says he doesn’t believe in jihad. All neighbours are watching. Nervous moments.

Back at the FBI... "Fingerprints are a match – it’s Yousef! We got him!" He's being brought to Manhatten.

Mohamed Salameh comes out of courtroom after being given sentence of 240 years along with other terrorist “Red” (240 years) and "Blind Sheikh" Omar Abdel-Rahman (life in prison).

Later in court Yousef says “I support terrorism as long as it is against US government and Israel. You are more than terrorists. You invented terrorism, you are using it every day, you are liars, hypocrites.”

Herman whispers to O'Neil: "Who's funding these terrorists? Who's paying for their defense?"

Judge makes comment about Islam and jihad. "You are not fit to uphold Islam. Your God is death." Judge wants to sentence him to death but instead he will do 240 years in isolation in jail.

He is flown by chopper to jail, past WTC. “If I'd had enough money and explosives, they wouldn’t be still standing.”

O’Neill and Clarke discuss following money trail – 'Tall One' - Saudi millionaire, paid for Yousef’s defence and supported Blind Sheikh. Name is Osama bin Laden - Clarke shows photo. OSB has declared fatwah/jihad against America. O'Neill: "We're at war!"

Afghanistan. Hill fort.

Western (ABC) film crew (including John Miller) walks nervously through crowds of men, one of whom spits at them. Crew searched by Afghanis who take their camera. Crew complains, guns are drawn. OK! OK!

Dr Ayman Al-Zawahiri (Liuetenant to OSB) and Muhammed Atef (Al-Qaeda military commander) greet camera crew. Crew want to speak with bin Laden.

Real footage of bin Laden (the interview).

June 10, 1998. CIA team watches the interview on the news back at HQ (Counterterrorism Center, CIA Langley, Virginia). CIA very angry that film crew got in without them knowing about it. Clarke and crew watch it at the White House and look very crestfallen. FBI team watches it at their HQ. Lots of footage of this interview is shown.

OSB: “We predict a black day for America!”

O'Neill wants extended complete version of footage from ABC, wants to meet with journalist John Miller. Gets info about meeting with Bin Laden from Miller “everyone went nuts when he turned up” (flashback of much shooting into the air and craziness amongst supporters). OSB blesses little boy.

O'Neill: "What was he like?"
John Miller: "Committed to his cause, whole new warrior, fought Russians, now want to fight us and believes he can win. We think Reagan won the Cold War. The Afghanis think they won the Cold War because they forced the Russians out and caused the 'Evil Empire' to crumble. Now they want us."

O’Neill realises gold dagger OSB sometimes wears is a signal of some kind to operatives watching – it's a message. Miller: "He did seem irritated that we weren't taking him seriously. Bin Laden was trying to provoke a response with his threats to hurt civilians"

Watching footage of Masoud, Northern Alliance commander of Mujehaddin.
Miller: "If it’s bin Laden you want. Masoud is your man, they hate each other. Are you thinking of hooking up?"

Caves in Afghanistan, Masoud’s stronghold, old military chopper arrives with Masoud in it, everyone cheers. FBI operatives already there. They meet Masoud. He’s happy to see them. They fly off together in his chopper.

Jury is watching bin Ladens’ whole speech. O'Neill paces outside. Mary Jo White (US Attorney S District of NY) gives O'Neill their decision: "Yes you have the legal basis to go after bin Laden. Indictment is in absentia. Are you bringing him in any time soon?" "I’m on it already!" They are nailing him for aiding and abetting Yosef, causing Black Hawk Down etc etc.

Masoud’s men fan out across Afghan countryside with FBI operatives. Arrive near Al-Qaeda camp and spy over camp. Masoud: "OBL is there. He raises money from mosques across the world, his money has been frozen for years."

They spot OBL. Masoud gives them his daily movements. FBI operative: “This is isolated, it’s perfect for us – it’s beautiful!”

CIA Langley, Virginia, June 1998. George Tenet (CIA director) gets briefing from "Kirk" (FBI operative) about the deal with OBL – details of how they will capture him.
"Patricia" (CIA Senior Analyst) asks for more info about mujehaddin and equipment.
Sandy Berger (National Security Advisor): "What are your intentions once you've siezed the target?"
Kirk: "We'll take him to Masoud’s cave, then Pakistan with the rendition team and then to NY."
George Tenet (CIA boss): I hope the indictment's solid - I don't want to get him all the way to NY and have some fancy lawyer get him off."
O'Neill: "Indictment is solid sir."
Paul Kessler (Chief of Operations, CIA): Is this covert or clandestine? Where’s the money coming from? I don't want to be the guy going in front of a special congresional coimmitte asking for money!"
Kirk: "Depends on if we succeed or not!"
Berger: "Do Masoud’s men know this is a snatch not an assassination?"
Kirk: "Absolutely"
Tenet: "It's not just killing OBL that worries me. What about the women and children in the compound? And do we trust Masoud?
Discuss pros and cons of Masoud. He grows heroin! He’s not a criminal, never been prosecuted for a crime. Deserves our backing and our support!

Want to discuss it privately. Kirk goes out of room.

Clarke to Kirk: "You go back and get them ready."
Kirk: "It's not a go?"
Clarke: "They are worried about political fallout and are not advocating assassination. Presidential directive that it would be OK if OBL were killed accidentally."
Kirk: "They flinch at the idea of wacking him? This is not about covering your own asses!"
O'Neill: "The fact is, terrorism is perceived by this administration as being a law and order problem. Period."
Kirk: "How do you win a law and orderly war?"
O'Neill: "You don't."

Cut immediately to real footage of Clinton press conference where he is saying “I did not have sexual relations with that woman.”

Clarke in car with O'Neill: "The President has assured me that this scandal won’t affect his decision-making."
O'Neill: "So it’s OK for us to kill BL as long as he didn’t give the order. Pathetic!"

Afghanistan, Masoud's stronghold. Chopper flies in.

Kirk tells operatives: "Janet Reno's signed off on it. We can kill him by accident, just not on purpose. He could get caught in the cross-fire."

Message comes in: Washington says it’s a go! They move out with Masoud.

CIA and FBI HQs with video linkup. All watching screens nervously. They are in audio contact with men on ground with Masoud in Afghanistan.
Afghani voice: "Afghanistan is standing by"
Patricia (CIA chick) to Berger on the video hookup: "Our people are in danger!"
Berger: "I understand that. But I don’t have that authority."
Patricia: "Excuse me sir but what authority do we have here?"
Random CIA dude: "Is the President leaving it up to us?"
Tenet: "The President has approved every plan presented for review."
Berger: "I can't call them until we're all on the same page"
Patricia: "The same page - is this some kind of code-speak, Sir?"
Afghani voice on audio hookup: "There are women and children near the target! They are moving towards the target! Do you want us to act now?"
Patricia: "Our people are in place!"
Tenet: "There are women and children nearby - how close are they? Can we clear them?"
Patricia to Clarke: "This is the nature of intelligence, sir, we rarely have the full information, We do the best that we can with the information"
Clarke: "But what do we know, Patricia?"
Patricia: "We know enough to try now. Now excuse me Sir, you are the National Security Adviser. Can’t you give the order?"
Berger to Tenet: Now look George, if you feel confident you can make a recommendation to the President yourself. "
Tenet: "So if it all goes bad it comes down on my head - like Janet Reno and Wako! The buck stops down the hall!"

Everyone looks down. Berger looks like he doesn't know what to say. Tenet laughs bitterly.
FBI ops and Masoud wait as the day dawns in Afghanistan.

Mahmoud: "Are there any men left in Washington or are they all cowards?"

John Miller watching video footage with Herman. Evil-eye is in Nairobi (reporter met him when interviewed OBL - Evil-Eye spat at him). There's a lot of intelligence chatter saying there's a plot by Al-Qaeda. OSB has a lot of cells. Can’t tell if it’s true. CIA checked walk-in informant's info (about plot to blow up Nairobi embassy) with Israeli Mussad and said to drop it.

Miller asks if they have any informants in Al-Qaeda. Herman says "I can't say" (meaning yes but I can't say).

Herman: "Embassy in Nairobi wants more money for security, State Dept considers it low budget priority."
Miller: "This guy is bad news – I guarantee it."

Kirk arrives at Nairobi embassy and is greeted by Ambassador.
Evil-eye approaches embassy with bomb in truck.
Evil-Eye: "Let me in! Let me in!"
Embassy security guard: "He has a gun! He has a gun! I need support!"
Evil-Eye throws a grenade into the compound. It explodes as those inside the embassy are discussing "unusual communications" they haven't been able to figure out.
Evil-Eye runs (away?) but other suicide bomber in the truck presses the button. Huge explosion. All embassy officials thrown across the room by the blast.

News report. Terrible death and destruction. 240 dead. Patricia marches angrily through CIA offices. Truck bomb also struck US embassy in Dar-es-Salam, Tanzania.

Bill Clinton in TV address: "We will use all the means at disposal to bring those responsible to justice."

Patricia storms into FBI meeting: "You should have ordered those people we had on the ground in Afghanistan to get bin Laden because we had him!”
Very upset - crying: "Those deaths. We’re responsible because we didn’t act on the info we had and we could have had him!"
CIA dude: "You don’t know for sure it’s him!"
Patricia laughs hysterically and leaves in tears. All top CIA guys look suitably chastised...

Nairobi – woman informs FBI (CIA? I'm getting confused who is who now! I think one guy is Kirk who was supposed to get blown up at the embassy. He has cuts on his face.) where Evil-Eye is. They arrive with guns. He has a gun. Chase him round the shacks, corner him. He rushes them, they arrest him.

Nairobi men surround them with machetes but the FBI/CIA talk their way out of it.

Clarke and O'Neill talk on the phone.
Clarke: "It's bin Laden all the way - although the CISA's witholding judgement. They are sending a team from the Washington Field office. I wisd they were sending you."
O'Neill: "What's Clinton going to do?"
Clarke: "They're talking about it as we speak."
O'Neill: "He has to do something. He has to act."
Clarke: "He's preparing a series of options but I can't say anything right now."

White House Situation Room, National Security Council, August 1998.
Tenet: "We have a number of suggestions. We must determine who is the enemy. We know OBL is responsible. Taliban have allowed himin the country and are protecting him.
Madeleine Albright (Secretary of State): "Taking on the Taliban would be a major miltary undertaking. President isn’t prepared to go that far in response to attacks on two embassies."
Clarke: "This isn't a game. We're at war!"
Albright: "The Attorney General's indictment name is bin Laden, not the Taliban. We need to focus on him and his terror network. What targets do you have in mind?
Clarke: Al Shifa. Pharmaceutical plant in Sudan. OBL is part owner in order to develop chemical and nuclear weapons"
Tenet: "Egyptian intel shows precursary substances assoc w chemical weapons"
Another CIA chick: "Need better intelligence on cthis facility before we consider any options"
Berger: "And if there's a nerve gas attack on NYC or a dirty bomb fired at a military base overseas and we had the opportunity to act??"
Albright: Do we have a retiatory plan I can present to the President? I'm waiting..."
Everyone looks dumbstruck.
William Cohen (Secretary of Defense): "We all agree we don't want to send in the ground troops. That would be a huge overreaction on our part. We can't do airstrikes because of flyover restrictions. So our best bet here will be missiles. Tomahawk missiles."
Tenet: "We can use President Reagan's missile strike on Libya as precedent. That way no-one on Capitol Hill can cry "assassination".
Albright: "Where? What are your targets?"
Clarke: The Al Shifa plant and we've got new intelligence that there's been a celebratory meeting between OBL and his top advisers."
Tenet gives location of meeting: "bin Laden will be chairing the meeting. Isolated, only jihadists, no civilian population."
Albright: "When?"
Tenet: "August 20th."

Slomo of Tomahawks being launched.

Clinton: The US launched an attack this morning on one of the most active terrorist bases in the world. Located in Afghanistan and operated by groups affiliated with OSB. Chemical weapons-related facility."

News report says that pharmaceutical plant was producing medicines and that there was no connection to bin Laden. Local people riot in the streets.

Reporter on the ground (John Miller): "Clinton is under fire from Republicans and media pundits – accusations that attack it is to distract people from Lewinsky affair." US flag burns.

OBL’s lieutenant calls news reporter (Nicholas Lanier - ABC Middle East Correspondent) to say the attacks have failed and OBL is alive. "Tell Clinton if he wants to fight, to come to Afghanistan and fight like a warrior. The war has begun!!!"

Clinton on news in background: "America will continue to lead the world's fight. For peace, freedom and security."

Lanier calls someone to tell them the news.

Al-Zawahiri in military convoy on two-way radio: "Attack the Northern Alliance! Let us show the world what happens to those allied with our enemies! Annihilate them!!!!!!"

Attack on Masoud camp from Taliban. FBI guy finds out they didn’t get OBL and tells Masoud.

Masoud: "OBL received notice from Pakistan. You know assassination was destined for failure. Because Washington informed Pakistan. This is your doing!"

Masoud is v angry w FBI guy. Battle rages, Masoud’s men take heavy casualties. He doesn't want any more help from FBI.

White House Situation Room
Tenet: "The Pakistani govt was informed when exactly of the Pentagon attack?"
Madeleine Albright: "The President feared missiles crossing Pakistan airspace could be mistaken as an attack from India, igniting a nuclear exchange between two countries looking for anyexcuse to go to war. We had no other choice!"
Tenet: "I realise that. But when did we let them know?"
Albright doesn't answer.
Tenet: "Madam Secretary. The Pakistani Security Service, the ISI, has close ties with the Taliban."
Albright: "We tried to time the disclosure through General Rolston so that any warning would be too late."
Tenet: "These are cruise missiles launched from thousands of miles waway. They take hours to honme in on their targets."
Albright: "We had to inform the Pakistanis. There are regional factors involved here!"
Tenet: "And the end result is that we've enhanced bin Laden's stature in the Islamic world. He's thumbing his nose at us!"
Berger: "That's the risk we take with covert military actions - Kennedy learned it with the Bay of Pigs, Reagan with Iran-Contra..."
Tenet: "When I took over at Langley I warned the administration about using covert operations to solve failed foreign policy..."
Berger: "You need to just do your job"
Tenet: "I am trying to do so sir - if you'll let me!"

O'Neill at party, wants to talk about "bad intel, bad PR" but they won't let him.

Khalid Sheikh Muhammad (Ramzi Yousef's uncle) arrives at Al-Qaeda training camp. Al Matar, Afghanistan, March 1999.

Men training. Weapons, guns, computers, bomb-making.

He greets OBL’s lieutenant. Suggests a collaboration to hijack and blow up lots of planes. Not an attempt to get his nephew out of jail, although it was an idea he had once. "I call it 'The Planes Operation'.”

Later that night in camp. Flames flicker from torches. A projector lights up a big screen with a viseo image of Bill Clinton. They shoot his image through the head and call him Satan. Everyone waves their guns in the air. "Clinton is Satan! Clinton is Satan!"

Making plans for Planes Operation. Once in Pakistan they must go alone to different places. Al-Zawahiri tells Khalid Sheikh Muhammad not to tell Ressam about their secret discussions or his meeting with OBL. "Ressam has his own path to follow."
Khalid Sheikh Muhammad wants money and help from OBL.
Al-Zawahiri: "You may begin preparations but it will be a limited operation - 10 planes is too many. Too many people involved. Much can go wrong. Targets must be carefully determined. Beauty must be its maximum casualities. Suggest December 31 1999. The millennium."
Khalid: "This is too soon! I don't have pilots to do this operation."
"With God's help you will."

US/Canada border, Port Angeles, Washington, December 14, 1999.

Sweaty guy driving car. Lots of police and security at border. He gets stopped by border guard because he’s so uptight. They want him to open the trunk. They find bomb-making raw materials. They try to arrest him but he runs. They get him. He’s Algerian - Ahmed Rassan. He has a NY phone number (Miskini's) written on a scrap of paper. They inform the FBI.

John O’Neill is told they may be dealing with multiple cells. Gets background info on movements of some people they are watching incl Miskini.
FBI dude: "Have we got enough to arrest this guy?"
O'Neill: "Not yet, but we have enough to get into his apartment and sniff around. Who knows what we may find."

Brooklyn, New York, December 20 1999.
In his apartment they find bottles of chemicals, wires, maps of LA and Manhatten, lots of credit cards and a gun.
FBI dude: "We have enough to arrest this guy, why are we screwing around?"
O'Neill: "We’re 11 days from the millennium. I want the whole network."

Herman tells O'Neill they have over 40 possibles that Miskini's linked them to in the last week. All under surveillance. O'Neill tells team they will round themn up on the 30th, which means they can hold them until after millennium.

FBI ops go back to house and arrest Miskini. News reports of many arrests of suspected terrorists.

FBI going through mounds of evidence, most of it in Arabic and encrypted. It will be hard to break it. Trying to get code-crackers but they just aren’t out there, and they have less than 40 hours. Fears of attack during millennium. News report says there is evidence that “may trace back to OBL with links via bomb-making materials to Yousef.”

Interviewing Miskini. Wanting to know who is the lead dog? What’s the big flame that you guys talk about on the telephone sheets? He won’t reply except to say Happy New Year in Arabic and “boom”.

Giuliani won’t cancel NY celebrations in Times Square. Tons of security.

Build-up to millennium celebrations as O’Neill questions terrorist suspect. "Is your mother proud of you? IS GOD PROUD OF YOU???? (and lots more yelling!)

Times Square, NYC, 31 December 1999

Massive celebrations. Heaps of security searching everyone. O’Neill v worried that there will be an attack. Dramatic music! Terrorist saying prayer! Worried faces! Drummer drums! Fireworks go off!

Celebration dinner of FBI dudes (and John Miller) after midnight because nothing happened. O'Neill: “We dodged a bullet tonight, but nobody bats a thousand - remember that."
Miller: "When is this ever going to end?”
They stand and sing “Danny Boy.”

American Airlines flights are leaving their airports on the morning of September 11 2001. Terrorists look at each other. They get knives and duct tape out of their bags in the overhead lockers. They start walking towards the cockpit...


They showed this disclaimer at the end as well:

The preceding movie is a dramatization that is drawn from a variety of sources including the 9/11 Commission Report and other published materials, and from personal interviews. The movie is not a documentary.

For dramatic and narrative purposes, the movie contains fictionalized scenes, composite and representative characters and dialogues, as well as time compression.

Phew! It's 7.20am and I've been rewriting this all night. I have to go to work in an hour or so. I'm not sure I can do this all again tonight - in fact I know I can't cos I'll be far too tired. I hope there's another Kiwi out there who might have a crack at it instead...

Technorati tags: , , , , , , , , .


Ted Howard said...

Hi Webweaver
Thanks for doing this!
I got onto this via your alerts on DailyKOS and I've sent that alert out to a bucnh of people and this has started a lot of complaints inot TVNZ.
I watched most of the programme last night, and I didn't think much of it. Too much overdramatisation, thin on some facts, and far too much sympathetic spin. The one line that stood out was the courtroom speech by the bomber as he was convicted to life imprisionment, stating that he was a terrorist, but that the real terrorists were the US and Israeli governments and how true thast is!

Ted Howard
Nelson, NZ

Anonymous said...

A heroic job -- thank you! I assume there are many similar comments waiting in the moderation queue as I post this.

Please forgive my "anonymity". I'm not a regular reader here and didn't want to go to the trouble of registering just to post this one comment.

-- Fool Zero, California, USA

Anonymous said...

Hello Webweaver, from Dinaelurus illumina.

I've been trying to find Clinton lawyer Douglas J. Band's email for the last hour on Google, but no luck. No luck either on Bruce Lindsey. Gotta jump off now. Thanks for all you've done.
Yes I did try the Clinton Foundation.

Someone else want to try?

My email is


amberglow said...

thanks for this.

Gary said...

I should note that the first scene is a lie. That incident was at another airport, at another airline. The checker was also following the American FAA guidelines at the time.

weez said...

Thanks very much for covering this!

It appears that the version which ran in NZ is the same as aired last night on the Seven Network in Australia. UK viewers can expect the same when the program airs there on BBC2 at 8:00PM BST 10 Sep 2006.

I have a digital recording of the program as it aired on Seven in Sydney last evening, but it's 2.8Gb in its current .ASF format, too big for CD-R.

Please see Australian bloggers' entries on mgk, Road To Surfdom and Barista.

Details are available on The SourceWatch wiki can be used to record observations and news about the program.

Porl said...

Please also see Moby's blog re the whole affair

Porl aka Stan

hoshie said...

Thanks for the play by play of this POS.

I watched Pt. 1 and found the whole affair biased, boring, and tedious. After I got done w/ it, I felt like I was indoctinated. My gut feeling is that anything that didn't mesh up with the 9/11 commission report, they simply made up.

Sad, sad, sad.